The fictional Colossus trilogy by D.F. Jones, set during the Cold War, features a super-computer that is granted control of the United States military defences, including its nuclear arsenal; the premise being that human emotions make for suboptimal outcomes. Its initiation sets in motion an unforeseen sequence of events that leads to humanity’s enslavement.
Whereas topical discussions today frame AI’s existential threats in terms of bad actors, it may be that the good, but unwise, intentions of its inventors are more problematic.
In Buddhism and Computing I posed a puzzle to express the beauty of mathematics in poetic form. It is a creative task that can’t properly be solved by machines – underlying my intention is the hint, “Start at the origin”, an instruction to practise the inner path of meditation, a long subjective journey to Keats’ realisation, ‘Beauty is truth, truth beauty’.
Creativity is a fundamental aspect of what it means to be human as distinct from machines, a key observation made by Ada Lovelace, who was clear about human intelligence being primary. Today, few analysts focus on the centrality of being human, Pope Leo being a notable exception.
As humans, we bear individual responsibility for our actions, which is predicated on agency. In the Attakārī Sutta: The Self-Doer (AN 6.38) the Buddha specifies six criteria for human agency: initiation, exertion, making effort, steadfastness, persistence and endeavouring. Hence, any digital technology may be evaluated simply according to whether – in the short-, medium- and long term – it increases or diminishes each of these agentic qualities.
But is the scenario in the introductory paragraph realistic? Standardised plain text formats, originally designed to facilitate global human communications, are now being leveraged by AI for machine-machine communications to autonomously (and relentlessly) solve problems. What problems? Not only planned defence of the realm – any piece of literature is now potentially natural language source code for so-called ‘vibe coding’, including the parsing and execution of nefarious plots in dystopian science fiction.
If we can practise contentment, as expressed in the Karaniyametta Sutta (SN 1.8), we may row back from nightmare scenarios like these. Practising stillness, which is of no advantage to machines, is a valuable step towards this (and to solving the puzzle). Failing that, in the Pabbatūpama Sutta (SN 3.25), King Pasenadi of Kosala is asked how he would respond to reports of mountains coming from every direction, crushing everything in their path. His response, endorsed by the Buddha, is to practise the Dhamma and cultivate moral virtue with skilful and meritorious deeds.
Sādhu!